I might be saying something controversial but I like cottage cheese. I always have. Call me crazy but the texture does not bother me and I can eat it pretty much any time of day. Except late night, I am not that crazy. So if you are already on the cottage cheese train this recipe is absolutely for you. And if you are not, humor me and try it anyway because the way this toast comes together you genuinely cannot taste the cottage cheese or feel the texture at all. It just tastes like creamy goodness with bright fresh tomatoes and fragrant basil in every single bite.

The olive oil toasted sourdough is the foundation that makes everything else on this toast work so well. Drizzling both sides of a thick slice of sourdough with olive oil before it hits the skillet gives you a completely different result from regular toasting. The olive oil creates a golden, slightly crispy exterior that is rich and savory and sturdy enough to hold all the cottage cheese and tomato toppings without getting soggy. It takes about two extra minutes and makes a noticeable difference in how the whole thing comes together and how satisfying it is to eat.

The cottage cheese spread goes on generously and gets seasoned with a good pinch of salt and pepper before the tomatoes go on. Heirloom tomatoes specifically are the move here because they have so much more flavor and variety than a standard grocery store tomato and at the height of summer they are so juicy and so sweet that they barely need anything else. Slice them thick so they are the star of every bite and salt them directly on top of the cottage cheese so the seasoning draws out their juices and makes them taste even more like themselves.

The basil chiffonade is the finishing touch that makes this look completely beautiful and adds that herby aromatic note that ties the tomato and cottage cheese together in the most satisfying way. Lightly roll the basil leaves and slice them into thin ribbons so they sit elegantly over the tomatoes rather than as a whole leaf that comes off in one bite. A final drizzle of your best olive oil over everything before serving and this is genuinely one of the most beautiful and nourishing breakfasts or lunches you can make in five minutes with almost zero effort.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Nicole Warren | Faith, Food & Motherhood (@nicole_thenomad)

Why You’ll Love This Recipe:

This is the cottage cheese recipe for people who think they do not like cottage cheese because the way it is prepared here you genuinely cannot taste it or feel the texture and all you get is creamy savory goodness
Olive oil toasted sourdough in a skillet rather than a regular toaster creates a completely different and significantly better result that is golden, crispy, and rich enough to hold all the toppings without going soggy
Six ingredients and five minutes for a high protein breakfast or lunch that looks completely stunning and tastes like something from a really good cafe
Peak summer heirloom tomatoes and fresh basil make this taste so fresh and vibrant that it genuinely requires almost no effort to produce something that tastes extraordinary

Key Ingredients:

Thick sourdough bread: The sturdy base that holds everything together. Thick cut slices are important here because they can support the weight of the cottage cheese and tomato toppings without bending or breaking. Sourdough specifically has a slight tang that pairs beautifully with the fresh tomatoes and basil
Olive oil: Used to coat both sides of the bread before toasting in a skillet for that golden crispy exterior that regular toasting simply cannot achieve. Use a good quality extra virgin olive oil because it adds both flavor and richness to every bite
Cottage cheese: One third cup spread generously over the warm toast as a creamy high protein base that is completely smooth and mild once it is spread and seasoned. Full fat cottage cheese gives you the richest most satisfying result
Heirloom tomato: The star of the whole toast and the ingredient that makes this taste so specifically like summer. Heirloom tomatoes have far more flavor and sweetness than standard tomatoes and sliced thick they are genuinely extraordinary especially at peak season
Fresh basil: Two leaves chiffonade into thin ribbons add the herby aromatic note that ties every other flavor together and makes this look as beautiful as it tastes. Fresh basil only here because dried basil is a completely different ingredient in this application
Flaky salt: The finishing seasoning that goes both on the cottage cheese layer and directly on the tomatoes to draw out their natural juices and make every component taste more intensely like itself

Tips for Success:

Toast the sourdough in a skillet with olive oil rather than a toaster for a golden crispy result that is so much better than regular toast and actually holds up under the toppings without getting soggy
Season the cottage cheese with salt and pepper before adding the tomatoes so the seasoning is distributed throughout the creamy layer rather than sitting only on the very top
Salt the tomatoes separately after placing them on the toast so the salt draws out their juices and intensifies their flavor while you are finishing the assembly
Slice the basil into a chiffonade by rolling the leaves tightly and cutting across into thin ribbons so they distribute beautifully over the toast rather than sitting in a pile in one spot

Storage:

This tomato basil protein toast is best enjoyed immediately after assembling while the sourdough is still warm and crispy and the tomatoes are at their freshest. The components do not store well assembled together as the tomatoes will make the toast soggy as they sit. If you want to prep ahead toast the bread fresh and have your cottage cheese and sliced tomatoes ready to assemble in about two minutes whenever you are ready to eat.

FAQ:

Can I use a different bread instead of sourdough?
Yes. Any thick slice of sturdy bread works here. A thick cut whole grain bread, a crusty Italian loaf, or a seedy multigrain bread all make excellent bases. The important thing is that the slice is thick enough to hold the toppings without bending and has enough structure to stay crispy after the olive oil toasting. Avoid soft sandwich bread which will not crisp up properly and will collapse under the toppings.

Can I use regular tomatoes instead of heirloom?
Yes but peak season heirloom tomatoes are strongly recommended when they are available because the flavor difference is immediately noticeable. If heirloom tomatoes are not accessible or not in season a vine ripened tomato is the next best option. Cherry tomatoes halved and layered on top also work beautifully and are available year round with more consistent flavor than regular beefsteak tomatoes out of season.

Can I add anything else to this toast?
Yes and there are so many great additions. A drizzle of balsamic glaze over the finished toast adds a sweet tangy element that pairs beautifully with the tomatoes and basil. A few shavings of parmesan on top add a salty nuttiness. A poached or fried egg on top turns this into an even more substantial meal. Everything but the bagel seasoning on the cottage cheese layer before the tomatoes is also a really delicious variation.